Shadowheart is one of the Best Baldur’s Gate 3 Companions, and Karlach offers a captivating romantic journey as well. But can you romance Shadowheart and Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3? Or do you only get to pick one?
Since Shadowheart and Karlach are both romanceable companions in Baldur’s Gate 3, players wonder if you can romance them.
Read on to know if you can romance Shadowheart and Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3 and which one to choose when you get the option. Let’s see if it will be as fun as it sounds!
In This Article
Can You Romance Shadowheart and Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3?
Yes! You can romance both Shadowheart and Karlach in BG3!
Although you can romance Shadowheart and Karlach in the game, you should note that you can only do so up to a point.
Once you speak to Shadowheart at the party, she tells you to meet her for wine later. Then as you go to sleep and wake up in the middle of the night, you get the option to spend time with either Shadowheart or Karlach.
So although you can romance them both throughout the game, you can ultimately only romance either Shadowheart or Karlach in BG3 till the end.
But interestingly, Karlach seems open to a polyamorous relationship, even though Shadowheart isn’t. This might probably be because Shaowheart gets jealous when you spend time with others in Baldur’s Gate 3.
Romance With Both Karlach & Shadowheart in Baldur’s Gate 3: Poly Romance
As for a poly romantic relationship with both Shadowheart and Karlach in BG3, during a conversation with Shadowheart, there is an option to share a moment with you. However, Karlach declines by saying, “Not this time.” This suggests that there may be a chance for a polyamorous relationship, and you might be able to romance Shadowheart and Karlach in the future.
But dialogue with Shadowheart in the game also suggests that while Karlach is open to a polyamorous relationship, Shadowheart is not.
Choosing Karlach or Shadowheart in Baldur’s Gate 3
On the cliff in BG3, you get the option to stare into Shadowheart’s eyes, then tell her she’s beautiful, and then lean in to share a kiss.
Unfortunately, at this point, you have to decide on spending the night with either Shadowheart or Karlach. Also, as mentioned before, it is a night of opportunity, one which won’t come for a while.
If you want to be with Shadowheart in BG3, you have to break things off with others. At the same time, Karlach is basically fine with you romancing others.
How to Romance Shadowheart and Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3?
Now you know all there is to know about romancing Shadowheart and Karlach in BG3 and when you’re asked to choose one of them. Let’s find out how to romance Shadowheart and Karlach individually.
How to Romance Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3?
Romancing Karlach requires you to gain her approval and show bravery. Here’s everything you need to do to Romance Karlach in BG3:
- Look for Karlach during the “Hunt the Devil” quest and protect her from Paladins.
- Gain her approval and show bravery and integrity.
- In Act I (Defend Tieflings), challenge Minthara.
- In Act II, get Infernal Iron to strengthen the bond with her.
- In Act III, interact with her and show interest.
How to Romance Shadowheart in Baldur’s Gate 3?
Romancing Shadowheart requires you to free her and gain her approval. Here’s everything you need to do to Romance Shadowheart in BG3:
- Look for Shadowheart in the Nautiloid ship and free her from the Mind Flayer Pod.
- Gain her approval by being “the good guy.”
- During the Save the Refugees quest, join the Refugee Celebration.
- Enjoy some quality one-on-one time with Shadowheart at the campsite.
- Progress through the game, communicate with her, and show interest.
Wrapping Up
So now we know that polyamorous relations are a bit tricky in the game, so if you want to romance Shadowheart and Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3 at the same time, you’ll be disappointed. If you want to be with Shadowheart, you have to break things off with others, and Karlach is basically fine with you laying with others.
Happy Gaming!
